University Circle ‘oil can’ church has buyer

Prayers may have been answered for the now-closed Church In The Circle/University Circle United Methodist Church, , a towering Cleveland landmark often affectionately called “The Holy Oil Can” due to its unique tall copper spire (LoopNet). CLICK IMAGES TO ENLARGE THEM.

Historic landmark may gain new use

Formerly the Church In The Circle/University Circle United Methodist Church, and always the Holy Oil Can, the landmark at 1919 E.107th St. has attracted a buyer. And it could be a game-changer for the heart of Cleveland’s growing health-care economy.

Terms of the pending sale, which hasn’t yet closed, weren’t publicly revealed. But the identify of the buyer has. The property went on the market in April 2025 with few if any potential religious landlords waiting in the wings.

According to a certificate of disclosure issued this week by the City of Cleveland’s Building Department as part of the sale transaction documentation, the buyer is a software company executive, computer scientist and inventor with 11 U.S. patents to his name — Jonathan William Piper of Waite Hill in Lake County.

Piper is the chief scientific officer and vice president of business development at MIM Software, a GE HealthCare Company with offices in Europe and China. Its headquarters is on Science Park Drive in suburban Beachwood.

NEOtrans has reached out to Piper via his LinkedIn account and to MIM Software’s Director of Marketing Jim Janek but has not heard back yet. This article will be updated with any replies.

Jonathan William Piper, an executive, computer scientist and inventor at MIM Software in Beachwood is the buyer of record for the historic, closed Methodist Church in University Circle (LinkedIn).

The seller is the East Ohio Conference of the United Methodist Church based in North Canton. It was asking $1.5 million for the property, according to its listing at LoopNet. Hanna Commercial Real Estate is the listing agency.

“No comment currently on any potential transactions, but we’ll be sure to let you know if and when we have permission to discuss anything,” said Bob Biggar, vice president at Hanna Commercial Real Estate in Cleveland.

Hanna Commercial Real Estate Managing Director Julie Sabroff said the owner is selling the property due to “the cost of maintaining the building in the face of declining membership.”

Given Piper’s position as vice president of business development and the church’s location in University Circle, the heart of Cleveland’s growing health care economy, it would not be surprising to see the church gain new life as offices, sales demonstrations and research center.

In 2022, the original Epworth-Euclid United Methodist Church had already lost its crown three times over as the tallest structure in University Circle. The latest height champion was under construction across the street — The Artist Apartment which is now gaining a neighbor only 5 feet shorter (Google).

It could become the new headquarters of MIM Software and/or an expanded office for GE HealthCare, which has its headquarters in downtown Chicago. A competitor, Canon Healthcare USA, is in the process of relocating its headquarters to 10500 Cedar Ave. in University Circle.

MIM Software in Greater Cleveland was assigned 11 U.S. patents developed and submitted for medical imaging over the past 15 years by Piper, previously of Cleveland Heights. Two of the patents were developed jointly with Jerimy Brockway.

It wouldn’t be the first church in the area to be converted into offices, labs and meeting space. Just up the hill, at 2200 Overlook Rd., the 1931-built First Church of Christ, Scientist with its 155-foot-tall bell tower, is today the EY-Nottingham Spirk Innovation Hub.

The Holy Oil Can is only slightly older. Built in 1928, it was declared a Cleveland Landmark by Cleveland City Council in 2013. Its building measures 54,081 square feet and sets on 1.64 acres. And it’s taller.

Like many of Cleveland’s historic churches, the original Epworth-Euclid United Methodist Church was built with a soaring sanctuary. It will be a challenge to convert to other uses (LoopNet).

For 56 years, the church and its 200-foot-tall spire, previously called the University Circle United Methodist Church and Epworth-Euclid United Methodist Church, was the tallest structure in University Circle.

Its height was eclipsed in 1984 by the 208-foot-tall, 16-story Cleveland Clinic’s Walker Center, 10524 Euclid Ave., built as the Ohio Industrial Commission’s rehab center.

That height was eclipsed twice since 2018 — first by the 20-story, 234-foot-tall One University Circle, 10730 Euclid Ave., then in 2024 by a building across the street from the Holy Oil Can.

The 24-story Artisan Apartments, 10700 Chester Ave., stands 267 feet tall. It is gaining a neighbor, East Stokes, 10700 Chester, that is only 5 feet shorter and is under construction is the same development as The Artisan, Circle Square.

END

Scroll to Top